DescriptionTopic:
Author (Yr):
Title:
Purpose/Research
Purpose of Study:
Journal________________________________________
QUALITATIVE REVIEW WORKSHEET
Questions/Inquiry
Qualitative Design
Research Question:
Biography
Case Study
Ethnography
Grounded Theory
Historical
Meta-synthesis
Narrative Analyses
Phenomenology
Other:
(Created10/05 by C. Crawford, Kaiser Permanente,
SCAL Nursing Research Program; revised 6/07)
Major Findings & Limitations
Findings: (continue on back)
Limitations: (continue on back)
Other Information Sources:
Literature Review
Editorial
Anecdotal
Sample
Number:
Type:
Age:
Gender:
Setting
Type:
Acute care hospital
Ambulatory Care
Community
Nursing Home
Other
Location:
Urban or Rural
Health Status:
Diagnosis
Other:
Other:
Coding/Analysis
Major Tools
Data Collection Methods(s)
Observation:
Participant
Group
Interviews:
Individual
Group
Document Collection
Written Accounts/Journals
Photographs & Video Tapes
Validity Assessment
Quality of Evidence
1. Researcher identifies, studies, and employs a
consistent tradition of inquiry
2. Begins with single focus/idea
3. Includes a rigorous and systematic approach to:
data collection
data analysis – process
data analysis – outcome
description of findings
4. Adequate sample selection method & size
5. Synthesizes data using multiple levels of
abstraction
Yes No
Yes No
Yes No
Yes No
Yes No
Yes No
Yes No
Yes No
Feasibility:
Could this practice change be implemented easily in your
organization and with minimal resources? Yes No
Axial
Authenticity Criteria:
Open
Confirmability:
Theme
Credibility:
Theoretical
Criticality:
Benefit/Risk:
Would the benefits of the practice change outweigh the risks to
the patients? Yes No
Taxonomic
Dependability:
Comments:
Other:
Transferability:
**Adapted from: Rosswum: Image J Nurs Sch, volume 31 (4). Fourth Quarter 1999. 317-322I; Ruskin (2001): The Qualitative Paradigm; and Polit & Beck (2004)
Purchase answer to see full
attachment
